Indie III (Desert CDs...)

These, I'd bring them to desert. I'd also recommend them as dessert, or even first course:
The Wall- Pink Floyd
In Rainbows- Radiohead
The Velvet Underground & Nico (played and composed by those of the same name)
Sigh No More- Mumford & Sons (I read someone defining their genre as "folk-rock". Sounds pretty good...)
Funeral- Arcade Fire